top of page
Search

Portugal: Controversial Savannah Lithium Mine's Final Environmental Plan

Writer: @ Cynthia Adina Kirkwood
@ Cynthia Adina Kirkwood
4 hours ago
5 min read

Prospecting in Covas do Barroso (Photo from United in Defense of Covas do Barroso)

Until December 4, public consultation is open on Savannah Resources' compliance report for its locally contested open-pit lithium mining complex, which would include a lavaria rock separating facility, waste facilities, water management structures, external and internal access roads, and an electrical line, on a project footprint of 336 hectares (830 acres).


The project relates to the Mina do Barroso for the mining of aplite-pegmatite with the objective of producing spudomene concentrate and value-added co-products of feldspar and quartz, according to The Barroso Mine Expansion Project: Evaluation of the Revised Project in the Scope of Article 16 of the RJAIA (Regime Juridico de Avaliaçao de Impacte Ambiental), Volume IV – Non-Technical Summary (NTR).


(Aplite-pegmatite is a granite that consists mainly of feldspar with embedded quartz. Pegmatites are important sources of metals, such as lithium, niobium and tantalum in addition to deposits of tin, beryllium and gems, according to Igneus Petrology. Spodumene is the hard-rock lithium-bearing mineral.)


It is lithium that is the big money-maker and sought-after critical raw material used in batteries for telephones, laptops and electric cars. In April 2025, the European Union designated 47 strategic raw material projects, including Savannah Lithium's, all of which will benefit from "simplified licensing provisions", according to the EC (March 25, 2025).


The European Union’s share of the global production of most critical raw materials is lower than 7 percent, according to the influential The Future of European Competitiveness (September 2024), by Mario Draghi, the economist who headed the European Central Bank (2011-2019).


Located in an ecologically balanced U.N. Globally Important Agricultural Heritage System, the proposed project in Covas do Barroso, Boticas Municipality, Vila Real District, would consist of two years of construction, 15 years of operation, and five years of decommissioning and final rehabilitation, amounting to 22 years, an increase from the previous 17 years, according to Projeto de Execução Relatório de Conformidade Ambiental do Projeto de Execução --RECAPE Relatório Base (November 4, 2026), Savannah Lithium.


By 5:30 p.m. on November 13, the first day of public consultation of the Environmental Impact Assessment and Planning Plan (RECAPE), 1,655 submissions already had been made through the online portal Participa, reported Público (November 13). On the morning of November 16, the number had risen to 5,651. The instructions for participation are below.


The purpose of the RECAPE, or final environmental impact assessment, is to verify whether the execution project has complied with the conditions imposed in the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), according to the Agência Portuguese do Ambiente (Portuguese Environment Agency).


In May 2023, the Portuguese Environment Agency issued Savannah's Environmental Impact Statement (DIA) a conditional favorable opinion.


The Unidos em Defesa de Covas do Barroso association expressed its "total rejection" on November 13 of the final proposal. It said that the documents attempt to correct an Environmental Impact Statement with inherent flaws, reported Público.


According to the association's statement, the procedure "is nothing more than a failed attempt to retroactively and artificially correct an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) with serious scientific and legal shortcomings".


For nearly a decade, Savannah Lithium's proposed project has been contested in Portuguese and European courts. Demonstrations, encampments and blockades have protested the proposed mine. In March 2023, a United Nations envoy contended that Barroso should not become "a sacrifice zone".


Local protest has broadened into a wider national and international coalition as the narrative about lithium mining being green is exposed as a fallacy, said the organizers of the third encampment in 2023.

Savannah's Chief Executive Officer, Emanuel Proença, said on the firm's website: "Savannah's team and our consultants have worked extremely hard to ensure that we have submitted a highly comprehensive RECAPE, having engaged regularly with APA and other key stakeholders in the licensing process since the 2023 DIA award.


"We firmly believe that the RECAPE, which follows on from the positive Phase 1 Definitive Feasibility Study results in July, demonstrates the high priority Savannah places on building an environmentally and socially sound final design and operating plan for Portugal."


Savannah CEO Proença said that the company expects a favorable decision in early 2027. The timing would allow the firm to "finalize various elements of the construction financing package, secure the other licences" and "begin the Project build next year".


Savannah Lithium is a subsidiary of Savannah Resources, which is listed on the Alternate Investment Market (AIM) in the London Stock Exchange’s international market for smaller firms, reported Mining.com (May 13, 2021).


In May 2023, the 313-page Opinion of the Assessment Committee specified three conditions, 43 elements, 18 measures of compensation and 180 measures of minimization to be included in Savannah’s Execution Project Environmental Compliance Report (RECAPE).


The three conditions were as follows:


1. The project cannot affect, directly or indirectly, registered real estate or that which is in the process of undergoing registration;


2. Prohibition of taking water from the Covas River, and


3. Deforestation must be done outside of the bird nesting season (which occurs between February and August), as well as the breeding season of the protected endangered Iberian wolf (which occurs between May and October).


The conclusion of the 23-page non-technical compliance report "demonstrates that the Execution Project for the expansion of the Barroso Mine . . . complies with the conditions, required documentation and measures established in the Environmental Impact Statement (DIA) dated May 30, 2023."


It reads:


"The Execution Project incorporates solutions that mitigate environmental impacts, including: an actual project footprint of 336 hectares, the elimination of taking water from the Covas River, and the establishment of a 100-meter protection buffer along the river.


"Rehabilitation is progressive: starting in Year 3, each area is restored as soon as it is vacated by mining operations. This involves backfilling the excavations, reapplying the topsoil (which had been stored in stockpiles), and re-vegetating the site with native species -- all in accordance with the PARP (Progressive Rehabilitation and Recovery Plan) -- thereby simultaneously reducing the disturbed area,


"Supplementary studies have been conducted, and the 15 compensation measures stipulated in the DIA (Environmental Impact Declaration) -- covering the Covas and Beça rivers, biodiversity, forests, local populations, cultural heritage and social aspects -- have been addressed. In addition, a Cork Oak Compensation Plan has been implemented as an extra measure.


"The reassessment of impacts confirms that the changes to the Detailed Design do not, in essence, alter the conclusions of the Environmental Impact Declaration (EIA): the main negative impacts (alteration of the terrain, land use, localized lowering of the groundwater table, and disturbances to local populations) can be mitigated or compensated for, while the positive effects-related to the utilization of a strategic resource and benefits to the local economy -- are further strengthened.


"The implementation of Monitoring Programs will allow for the tracking of environmental changes throughout the various phases of the Project, enabling the adjustment of measures, whenever necessary.


"No knowledge gaps were identified that would call into question the conclusion of the RECAPE (Report on Compliance with Environmental Impact Statement Conditions); the conditions required to fulfill the measures stipulated in the Environmental Impact Statement (DIA) are considered to be secured for the pre-construction, construction, operational, and decommissioning phases."


The Author


I live in the foothills of the Serra da Estrela which, until February 2022, also had been considered for lithium exploration. I oppose lithium mining in Portugal.



First, you must register if you have not already done so. If you have, go to #8:


1, Click on Registo in the upper right-hand corner;

2. Click on Individual;

3. Fill in your name, email, password, confirmation of password and, from a drop-down menu, your concelho (municipality);

4. Tick the Agreement with Conditions on the bottom left-hand corner;

5. Click Submeter (Submit) in the bottom right-hand corner;

6. You will receive an email:

8. There are three mustard yellow boxes: Participar (Participate), Seguir (Follow) and Partilhar (Share);

9. Click on the first and choose from a drop-down menu. Click on DISCORDANCIA if you object, for example, and CONCORDANCIA if you support it.

10. Add text;

11.Click on Submeter;

12. Done.




 






















 
 
 

Comments


​FOLLOW ME

  • Facebook

© 2017-2026 by Cynthia Adina Kirkwood

bottom of page